Creamy Rice Pudding Recipe

flavored with cinnamon and lemon

by Mar

This easy, homemade creamy old fashion rice pudding recipe is one of my favorite childhood desserts. With just enough sweetness, flavored with lemon and cinnamon, delicious while still warm but also cold, this is probably the easiest international dessert recipes ever.

And, best of all  – made with everyday 3 basic ingredients. A bawl of this warm, comforting, rich, creamy rice pudding is always bringing me back childhood memories…

Better than Rizogalo?…

With no eggs and no butter but with tangy lemon zest favor, I find it better than Greek rice pudding rizogalo. May be a personal taste, but just make it and convince yourself of this fabulous Romanian version.

creamy old fashioned rice pudding

creamy old fashioned rice pudding

Every once in a while, I like to upgrade this recipe and make it sweeter – so I top it with fruit jams and some chopped walnuts. That, is the ultimate heavenly rice pudding delish. Just follow the recipe below to start making it happen.

You can easily make it vegan

Just replace regular milk with almond milk, coconut or oat milk and you have a vegan rice pudding recipe instead. So, what do we need for this rice pudding recipe?


🥛 Creamy Rice Pudding Recipe Ingredients

Three basic ingredients and some extra flavors and let’s start cooking.

rice pudding ingredients

rice pudding ingredients

  • Short-grain / Arborio (risotto) rice, but any kind will do
  • Whole milk – for intense milk flavor (coconut / almond milk for vegans)
  • Sugar – white, regular sugar
  • Pinch of salt for taste
  • Lemon zest for flavor
  • Vanilla extract for flavor
  • Cinnamon to serve – optional
  • Sour cherry jam to serve – optional
  • Ground walnuts to serve – optional


🍚 Creamy Rice Pudding Recipe – How To Make It

Old fashioned rice pudding recipe is cooked on the stove-top, blending all the ingredients in a saucepan and simmering for a while, until the rice thickens and is cooked trough. It will require frequent stirring, so you cannot walk away from it. Like cooking the famous risotto – it takes commitment and attention. Make sure you have all ingredients at hand.

1️ Step one: Put the rice and water to boil

Place the rice into a strainer and rinse well under running cold water. Transfer the rice, the water, and salt to a medium sized (preferably heavy bottomed) saucepan and bring to a boil. Reduce heat to a gentle simmer and cook until most of the water is absorbed (about 7-10 minutes). Stir occasionally, at 2-3 minutes.

how to make rice pudding

how to make rice pudding

2️ Step two: Add the milk and sugar

Add half of the milk into the saucepan and keep cooking on medium-low heat. Cook for another 10 minutes, stirring very often. The rice will start to expand, absorbing more liquid as it cooks. Add the rest of the milk and the sugar. Keep cooking at lowest heat, on a gentle simmer for the rest of the time – stirring frequently to not let it burn from sticking to the bottom of the pan.

After other 15-20 minutes the pudding will thicken and the rice will become tender. I like to cook the rice al dente. Depending on the rice type, usually 40 minutes of slow cooking will be enough. The rice will continue cooking even after we take it off the heat, so have a taste and if it reached the al dente point, turn off the heat.

Note: the consistency of this recipe is just as you see in the photo below. If you like a more liquid, creamier pudding, add more water at the beginning or milk (+1/2 cup or more) while cooking. Keep in  mind that as it cools off it will become even more consistent and absorbing all the liquid. So now is the time to correct the amount of the liquid, or if you prefer it just like I made it – keep the recipe as it is.

easy rice pudding recipe

3️ Step three: Add the lemon zest and vanilla

Once you turn off the heat, add the lemon zest and the vanilla extract. Give it another stir to combine everything well and that’s it! The pudding is ready to be served. The smell is divine. There’s no point to wait. 🙂


🥄 Serving This Creamy Old Fashioned Rice Pudding

The old fashion recipe is usually served with lots of ground cinnamon on top. Serve this rice pudding in individual bawls or cups and sprinkle with cinnamon to your taste.

If you like an upgrade to this recipe, add 1-2 tbsp of your preferred jam and some chopped walnuts on top. Just for pure deliciousness. Indulge!

delicious rice pudding


Other delicious recipes for your family:


Creamy Rice Pudding Recipe (Better Than Greek Rizogalo)

This easy, homemade creamy old fashion rice pudding recipe is one of my favorite desserts. I find it better than Greek rice pudding rizogalo.
Course Dessert
Cuisine International, Romanian
Keyword easy, milk, rice, rice pudding
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 40 minutes
Total Time 45 minutes
Servings 4 servings


  • cups (250g) risotto rice
  • 1/2 cup (120g) sugar
  • 1 cup (250ml) water
  • 3 cups (750ml) milk
  • 1/3 tsp salt
  • lemon zest from 1 lemon
  • 1 tbsp vanilla extract
  • ground cinnamon (to taste)
  • fruit jam, walnuts to serve (optional)


  • Rinse and drain the rice. In a heavy bottom medium sized saucepan combine the rice, water and salt. Bring to boiling point stirring often. Let it absorb the water for about 7-10 minutes on medium heat.
  • Lower the heat and add half of the milk. Stir continuously and cook for another 10 minutes, as the rice is expanding and absorbing more and more liquid. Add the rest of the milk and the sugar (if you prefer a more creamy pudding now it's the time to add 1/2 cup more milk to the recipe).
    Continue cooking, stirring gently and consistently so the rice doesn't stick to the pan for another 15-20 minutes, until the pudding thickens and the rice is cooked trough.
  • When the rice is done, turn off the heat and add the lemon zest and the vanilla extract. Give one last stir to blend all the flavors together and serve immediately sprinkled with ground cinnamon to your taste.
    To variate, add some fruit jam and chopped walnuts on top as well. Yum!


This is TASTY. Save it or Share to inspire someone today. 🙂

You may also like

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.